Field notes
Carbon removal credits: biochar, DAC and the rest
How carbon removal credits differ from avoidance credits, what biochar, direct air capture, rock weathering and tree planting store, and how long each lasts.
- By
- Vida Carbon Guide editorial team
- Published
- Reading
- 4 min
Short answer
A carbon removal credit represents one tonne of CO2 taken out of the atmosphere and stored, and the main differences between removal types are how long the carbon stays put, how well the tonnes can be measured and how much each tonne costs.
Key takeaways
- Avoidance credits stop emissions that would have happened; removal credits pull CO2 that is already in the air back out.
- Storage time ranges from decades for trees and soil to many centuries or longer for geological storage.
- Engineered removals such as direct air capture are easier to measure but cost far more per tonne than nature-based ones.
- A removal credit still needs the usual checks: registry, methodology, verification and retirement in your name.
Most carbon credits sold so far have come from avoidance projects: a landfill captures methane it would have vented, or a forest is protected from logging. Removal credits work differently. They represent CO2 that was already in the atmosphere and has been pulled back out and stored. As more companies set net-zero targets, removals are getting more attention, and more marketing. Here is what the main types actually do.
What is the difference between avoidance and removal?
An avoidance credit stops an emission from happening, while a removal credit takes a tonne of CO2 out of the air and stores it somewhere.
Both are measured in tonnes of CO2 equivalent and both are issued and retired through registries, as our guide to what a carbon credit is explains. The difference is the direction of the flow. Avoidance keeps carbon from going up. Removal brings it back down.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has said that removing CO2 will be needed to counterbalance emissions that are hard to cut, such as some from farming and heavy industry. That is why many climate targets distinguish between the two and limit how much avoidance can count toward a net-zero claim.
What are the main types of removal?
Removal methods fall into nature-based approaches that use plants and soils and engineered approaches that use machines, minerals or industrial processes.
| Method | How CO2 is removed | Where it is stored | Typical storage time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tree planting and reforestation | Trees absorb CO2 as they grow | Wood, roots and soil | Decades to a century or more, if the forest survives |
| Soil carbon | Changed farming practices build soil organic matter | Soil | Years to decades; can reverse if practices change |
| Biochar | Plant waste is heated without oxygen into a stable charcoal | Soil or materials the char is mixed into | Often estimated at centuries for the stable fraction |
| Enhanced rock weathering | Crushed silicate rock spread on fields reacts with CO2 | Dissolved carbonate, eventually the ocean | Thousands of years or more |
| Direct air capture with storage | Machines pull CO2 from air and pump it underground | Deep geological formations | Thousands of years or more, if well sited and monitored |
| Bioenergy with carbon capture | Biomass is burned for energy and the CO2 is captured | Deep geological formations | Thousands of years or more |
Storage times in the table are broad ranges used in the scientific literature, not guarantees for any single project.
Why does storage time matter so much?
A tonne emitted from fossil fuel warms the climate for centuries, so a removal that only holds carbon for a few decades does not fully balance it.
This is the permanence question. Forests and soils can lose their carbon through fire, drought, pests or a change in land use. Standards handle this with buffer pools and monitoring periods, which our cookstove, rice and forest projects guide describes. Geological storage and mineral weathering lock carbon away for far longer, which is one reason buyers pay much more for them.
When you compare offers, ask how long the carbon is expected to stay stored, what happens if it is released, and who is responsible for monitoring.
Why are some tonnes so much more expensive than others?
Engineered removals cost far more per tonne because they need energy, equipment and storage infrastructure, while nature-based removals rely on plants doing most of the work.
Price differences between removal types are large, often an order of magnitude or more. A tree planting credit and a direct air capture credit are both "one tonne removed," but they are not the same product. The cheaper option usually comes with more uncertainty about measurement and permanence. The expensive option usually comes with tighter measurement and longer storage.
Neither price tells you whether a specific project is good. It tells you what kind of risk you are buying.
How do you check a removal credit?
Run the same checks as for any credit, then add questions about measurement and storage.
- Which registry issued the credit, and what is the project ID?
- Which methodology does the project use, and has it been assessed against the Integrity Council's Core Carbon Principles?
- How are the removed tonnes measured: direct measurement, sampling or modeling?
- How long is the carbon expected to stay stored, and how is that monitored?
- Is there a buffer or insurance for reversals?
- Are credits issued after removal has happened, or sold in advance as future deliveries?
The last question catches many buyers out. Some removal projects sell forward contracts for tonnes they plan to remove in later years. That can be how new plants get built, but a promise is not yet a credit. Our homepage checklist flags future-delivery offers along with the other common warning signs.
Should you buy removal credits as an individual?
If you want to compensate for emissions you cannot avoid, a small amount of durable removal is a reasonable choice, but treat it as a contribution, not as a way to cancel your footprint.
Some buyers split their budget between lower-cost, well-verified credits and a smaller amount of long-duration removal. Others prefer to spend the money on cutting their own emissions first. Both are defensible. What is not defensible is buying cheap credits labeled "removal" without checking what kind they are.
This note is educational only and is not investment advice. Carbon credits are not a savings product.
Questions readers ask
Are removal credits always better than avoidance credits?
Not always. A well-run avoidance project can be worth more than a badly measured removal project. Removals matter because reaching net zero requires balancing leftover emissions with tonnes taken out of the air, but each credit still has to pass quality checks.
Why is direct air capture so expensive?
CO2 makes up a small fraction of the air, so machines have to move and process a huge volume of air and use a lot of energy to release and compress the captured gas. Costs per tonne are expected to fall as plants scale up, but they remain far above most nature-based credits.
What happens if a forest that generated removal credits burns down?
The stored carbon goes back into the air. Most forest standards hold back part of each project's credits in a buffer pool to cover losses like this, and they cancel buffer credits when a reversal happens. Whether the buffer is big enough is one of the main quality questions for forest credits.
Sources
- IPCC Sixth Assessment Report, Working Group III: Mitigation of Climate Change
- Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market: Core Carbon Principles
- US Department of Energy: Carbon Dioxide Removal
Independent educational guide, relaunched in 2026. Not affiliated with Vida Carbon Corp, Vida Energy or any carbon-credit seller. Nothing here is investment advice.